This week’s review was delayed because I had far too much to say. I’ve fallen decisively in love with both of the novels I am reviewing, so the technical challenge was to steer between two extremes: “inarticulate flail and squee in direction of beloved works” versus “thesis-length disquisition.”
The mystery and me
My personal relationship to the mystery form has changed over the years. As a kid, I didn’t like surprises. I grew up moving every year and a half on average, and those dislocations were announced with very little advance notice. On one memorable occasion, my father learned that the plant that supplied what he sold had blown up the night before, which kind of changed plans.
Mystery stories depend on a fair bit of suspense; I loved reading them, but I could only take so much before I got the problem established and then skipped to the end to see what happened. Then I read backward from there to see how it was proven.
Only as an adult in a relatively stable living situation did I join (even provisionally) the readers who didn’t want to know up front how it ended.
Kid-me read like a mathematician, starting from the initial setup of the problem, proceeding to what-is-to-be-shown, then getting from point A to point B by making the case. Yet one more reason I loved geometry and logic: they mirrored my childhood reading habits.
Mysteries are my brain candy. They create worlds where we understand by the end how things actually played out, and who did it. As an adult, I like the not-known and the guessing, and with the years I have developed a taste for two other forms that depend on surprise: humor and horror. So paradoxically, my favorite mysteries leave something unresolved.
The fascination of mystery structure in a series is how much will be wrapped up by the end, how much will be solved in the course of the story, and what questions will never be answered.
A cozy mystery with occasional explosions
Sunstruck is an urban fantasy / cozy mystery set in Spokane, Washington, and the first act of a series; Ancillary Sword is space opera (but really, it’s a cozy mystery with occasional explosions), and the second act of a trilogy. Both stories play with mystery subplots, equal parts ‘whodunit’, ‘who is WHO’, ‘howdunit’ and ‘zomg, there are yet more disturbing details unaccounted for.’ Continue reading →